In addition to the
beautiful story that relate this charming series, I chose it also because it picked
up some historical events that takes us back in time; and in the second season
of the series we are served. It opened on a war setting, that announced the beginning
of the first world war which has totally change the lives of the inhabitants,
furthermore; the house is going to be transformed into a hospital and its
gentlemen into soldiers and army agents, and its ladies to tender nurses.so how
much does this war affect our dear characters? And does it change anything in
the relation they had between each other (mainly downstairs, and upstairs
relation)?
In 1916 the war blew up in
Europe, and men has to enlist in the army; whatever their society class, Mathew
crawly as the first episode of second season had shown, became an Officer on
the front, he is now equal to the other, no classes matter, they are all in the
same situation, fitting for the same ground; Thomas and William joined the war
too, very horrible things happened there.
To sum up, Thomas has as
usual find a way to save his neck, he gets injured on purpose in order to be
sent home, William and Mathew fought courageously but they unfortunately get
injured together at war. Matthew suffers a back injury that means he will
likely never walk (or perform, shall we say, husbandly duties) again! And
William died peacefully after his marriage with Daisy who did not want to marry
him but did it because he was dying.
In the house lot of things
have changed too, starting with the décor, the small country hospital due to
not enough room for all the recovering officers, Lady Grantham is approached by
Isobel Crawley and Dr. Clarkson about turning Downtown Abbey into a
convalescent home, and it is what happened, Cora is resistant, but the entire
family is persuaded to help any way they can, and offering their home seems to
be the best solution.
This shakes up the roles
of both family and staff, but everyone get involved in this humanitarian aid;
starting with Sybil, who went to a nursing school and become a nurse to help
the injured soldiers, Mary, Edith and the servants provided assistance too. And
we can mention that somehow this war has unify them and give to downtown abbey
a more realistic image than in the first season which was more superficial in
my point of view.
However; romance had
been also present in this second chapter, and disillusion as well, mainly to
poor Mary who had been announced that Matthew is now engaged to a young woman
named Lavinia Swire, and it is not everything, not yet! Lady Edith’s fumbling
lead in the romance department (it’s really not wise to set your sights on
someone who’s already married), Lady Mary hooks up with Sir Richard Carlisle although
it seems like more of a business proposition than a romance. Especially when he
offers to cover up her indiscretion. And Sybil finds herself falling for
chauffer Tom Branson, which is not at all befitting a lady of her status.
Ahh what a passionate season!
Full of suspense and romantic intrigue, still the only good news we receive
this season is that the war is over.so what next!
Ce commentaire a été supprimé par l'auteur.
RépondreSupprimerThanks for your analysis of the 2nd season and the war. However, I disagree in part with your analysis:
RépondreSupprimer- contrary to what you say, the war does not erode existing social barriers in the series. Gentlemen become officers while servants become ordinary soldiers. Of course in the trenches they experience similar hardships, but the class barrier survives. We should note also that when Downton becomes a convalescent home, it is reserved for officers only !
- you could have insisted more on Thomas's self-inflicted wound to escape the trenches. This is a very interesting episode from a historical point of view, because it alludes to the reluctance of soldiers to be butchered in the war and indirectly remind us of the hundreds of soldiers executed for refusing to fight (in fact, if Thomas’s deception had been caught, he would have been executed for desertion). The fact that this role is played by the unpleasant Thomas may indicate that the series does not take a sympathetic view of this behavior (which stands in opposition to the contemporary attempt to restore the memory of the executed soldiers)
This reminds me that so far, you havent really picked up a theme to assess the historical authenticity of the series. You seem to comment often on the class relation, so I think you could focus on this, maybe.